One of the things that too many small businesses do when they advertise is to try to pack the ad with everything that could possibly be of interest to any potential customer.
After all, advertising is too expensive to waste any opportunity to sell everything to anyone.
That’s logical, isn’t it?
None the less, it’s guaranteed to be bad advertising.
Look at this Yellow Pages Ad
It could easily be a radio ad, or television ad. The style isn’t at all different, merely the details of the execution.
And as a Yellow Pages ad, listed with all competitors under “Dentists,” Dr. Whacksem is likely to get a few calls from this ad. He will, however, always suspect that his ad isn’t very efficient. It doesn’t draw enough business for what he’s paying. He’ll blame the medium. “My radio rep told me that Yellow Pages don’t work. She was right.”
She’s wrong. So’s the doctor.
The medium isn’t the problem, the message is the problem.
What’s the message? Ah. There’s our problem.
What is his message? That he works on kids, and their parents, and older people, too? That he will accept insurance payments or make a payment plan? That he does fillings, and teeth whitening, and root canals, and extractions? That he does crowns and bridges and bonded porcelain? That he uses x-rays? That his staff is professionally trained? That he’s “mercury-free,” (whatever that means)?
What is Dr. Whacksem’s message? I’ve counted at least fifteen, and that doesn’t even count him telling you how to get in touch.
Without scrolling back up, how many can you remember? Humm. And that was only two paragraphs ago, after I drew your attention to it.
Nobody will remember a list.
Listing your services, or your products, is bad advertising.
Instead of getting more information to more people, you’ll accomplish exactly the opposite. The message becomes part of a blur in the minds of the people who are already being clobbered by hundreds of other ads every day.
This ad doesn’t say anything “salient,” anything a potential customer can relate to. Without that salience, it doesn’t stand out. It doesn’t get remembered. To maximize your impact, you need to give this ad salience.
You need to make one simple, easily remembered point to one particular group of people.
Some small business people get it right away. Many do not. Frankly, most do not.
“You’re telling me NOT to tell people that my dental office works on children, and adults, and old people. You want me not to tell people we do root canals, and teeth whitening, and x-rays, and takes most insurances? That’s crazy. What if someone needs a crown, and they don’t see that in my ad?”
What if someone needs a crown, and you didn’t manage to get their attention in the first place? How many people do you believe actually read your list of services?
Whatever the size of your business, your advertising will have a bigger impact if you limit your ads to one simple easy to remember message.
Consider this ad from one of our first dentist’s competitors:
First, notice the headline – “good news for high fear dental patients.” How many people are afraid to even be examined by a dentist? And even those who aren’t afraid will appreciate the promise of “Soft Touch.” Everyone will appreciate that their comfort is this dentist’s first concern.
Notice, too, that the ad doesn’t list all of basic services. Truthfully, though, doesn’t every dentist do fillings? Root canals? Cleaning? Doesn’t every dentist use x-rays?
Do we even notice that these things are missing? Do we care?
No, we don’t.
What do we remember?
Instead, we remember that Soft Touch Dentistry doesn’t want us to hurt, or to be afraid.
The second ad makes much more impact, doesn’t it?
OK, but what happens when someone who’s not afraid of the dentist hits the Yellow Pages? Which ad is she drawn to?
Care to speculate?
Of course it’s the second one. Whether she needs a cleaning, a root canal, or a crown, our dental prospect is still not likely to even notice the first ad, and will react positively to the second. The second ad, the highly-focused single message ad, is the one our dental prospect will read. She’s also more likely to phone for an appointment.
So, by narrowing the focus to a single point, we actually broaden the appeal of the ad. Wow.
Then, there’s cost.
And there’s something odd happening here. With all of its additional impact, the second ad takes only about 60% of the space that it’s competitor does. Soft Touch Dentistry makes a much bigger impact with a substantially smaller ad. Double wow. How much money will this save Soft Touch over the year? Better yet, how many more impressions can Soft Touch Dentistry purchase with the same budget?
OK, one last thought: the Advertising Performance Equation (APE) represents the relationship between your message, the frequency of that message delivery to an audience, the customers’ experience with you, your market potential, and resultant sales.
All other factors being equal, and without going into the math, making your ad twice as memorable will double the percentage of your advertising driven sales.
And we like to double the catch when we’re fishing for customers.
Got questions about helping people to remember your advertising? Drop Chuck a note at ChuckMcKay@ChuckMcKayOnLine.com. Or call him at 304-208-7654.